Made in Canada
All proposalsTBL / UTA

TBL and UTA trade

cw_user_6fq4c9hoOct 31, 2026
37%
chance it happens

Model says TBL says no.

Vote below to see if readers agree.

TBL37%to acceptSays no

$582Kover the cap

UTA39%to acceptSays no

$4.41Mcap space after

Who says no?

22 votes

Analysis

Tampa Bay is the likelier team to pass: Guenther, Schmaltz and the first are a substantial return, but moving Kucherov during a strong Cup run would cut into its best chance to win now. Utah could justify paying for his elite scoring, but only if Kucherov’s trade clause permits the move and Schmaltz waives his no-move clause.

Assets

TBLReceives+$3,309,524
  • Dylan Guenther
    RW23$7,142,8577 yrs, UFA
    2025-26: 79 GP, 40 G, 33 A, 73 P
  • Nick Schmaltz
    C30$8,000,0008 yrs, UFA
    2025-26: 82 GP, 33 G, 41 A, 74 P
  • 2028 1st round pick
UTAReceives-$3,309,524
  • Nikita Kucherov
    RW33$9,500,0001 yr, UFA
    2025-26: 76 GP, 44 G, 86 A, 130 P
  • Yanni Gourde
    C34$2,333,3335 yrs, UFA
    2025-26: 82 GP, 9 G, 19 A, 28 P

Why the model says so

Guenther, Schmaltz and a first are a serious offer, but Tampa Bay is a Cup contender built around Kucherov and would lose its best scorer.

Kucherov could lift Utah’s playoff offense, but Guenther’s long-term scoring, Schmaltz’s two-way play and a first are a steep price for a 33-year-old pending UFA.

The deal

Tampa Bay Lightning acquire Dylan Guenther, Nick Schmaltz and a 2028 1st-round pick (FLA) from the Utah Mammoth for Nikita Kucherov and Yanni Gourde.

Team by team

TBL

Tampa Bay would replace Kucherov’s elite scoring with two productive forwards: Guenther scored 40 goals last season and has six years left after this one at a $7.14 million cap hit, while Schmaltz brings center/right-wing versatility and strong two-way play. Guenther is on injured reserve, though, and neither replaces Kucherov’s 130-point production last season for a Cup contender.

UTA

Utah would get a game-breaking winger who had 28 points in 19 games, plus a strong defensive center in Gourde. Kucherov’s $9.5 million deal expires after this season and carries a modified no-trade clause; Gourde’s $2.33 million cap hit runs four more years after this one. Utah would give up two core forwards under long-term contracts and Florida’s 2028 first, whose draft position is unknown.

Discussion

Discord