Made in Canada
All proposalsDAL / TBL

DAL and TBL trade

cw_user_6fq4c9hoOct 31, 2026
25%
chance it happens

Model says DAL says no.

Vote below to see if readers agree.

DAL25%to acceptSays no

$4.48Mcap space after

TBL50%to acceptSays yes

$968Kover the cap

Who says no?

18 votes

Analysis

Dallas is likely to pass: Kucherov could raise its Cup ceiling now, but losing both Robertson and Harley makes the return too old and too short-lived for a contender. Tampa Bay has little reason to break up a strong contender in October, though the younger package makes the offer worth considering if the required clauses can be cleared.

Assets

DALReceives-$3,695,334
  • Nikita Kucherov
    RW33$9,500,0001 yr, UFA
    2025-26: 76 GP, 44 G, 86 A, 130 P
  • Victor Hedman
    D35$8,000,0003 yrs, UFA
    2025-26: 33 GP, 1 G, 16 A, 17 P
  • Yanni Gourde
    C34$2,333,3335 yrs, UFA
    2025-26: 82 GP, 9 G, 19 A, 28 P
TBLReceives+$3,695,334
  • Jason Robertson
    LW27$12,000,0001 yr, UFA
    2025-26: 82 GP, 45 G, 51 A, 96 P
  • Thomas Harley
    D25$10,587,0008 yrs, UFA
    2025-26: 70 GP, 6 G, 30 A, 36 P
  • Emil Hemming
    RW20$941,6673 yrs, RFA
    Drafted 2024, #29 overall
  • 2027 2nd round pick

Why the model says so

Dallas would pay with two core players, Hemming and a second-rounder for Kucherov’s expiring deal and two veterans in their mid-30s. That is too much long-term cost for the immediate upgrade.

Robertson and Harley give Tampa Bay a credible younger core, with Hemming and the second adding value. Moving Kucherov and Hedman while the Lightning are contending is still a major call, especially with Robertson’s deal expiring.

The deal

Dallas Stars acquire Nikita Kucherov, Victor Hedman and Yanni Gourde from the Tampa Bay Lightning for Jason Robertson, Thomas Harley, Emil Hemming and a 2027 2nd-round pick (NSH).

Team by team

DAL

Dallas would get an immediate scoring upgrade in Kucherov, who had 130 points last season, plus a strong defensive center in Gourde. But it would give up 27-year-old Robertson and 25-year-old Harley for a 33-year-old winger who can become a UFA after this season, a 35-year-old Hedman with two more years at $8 million, and a 34-year-old Gourde with four more years at $2.33 million.

TBL

Tampa Bay would replace Kucherov’s scoring with Robertson’s 45-goal, 96-point production from last season and get a younger offensive defenseman in Harley. Robertson’s $12 million deal expires this season, but Harley has seven more years at $10.587 million; Hemming, a recent late first-round pick on a $941,667 entry-level deal, and Nashville’s second-rounder add longer-term value. Harley’s no-move clause and Hedman’s no-move clause would require their approval.

Discussion

Discord