$227Kcap space after
TBL and DAL Trade ( Roboertson for kucherov )
Model says TBL says no.
Vote below to see if readers agree.
$3.29Mcap space after
Who says no?
12 votesAnalysis
Tampa Bay is likely to pass: swapping Kucherov for another pending UFA does not give a contender enough long-term security to justify the extra cap hit and two second-round picks. Dallas would have a strong reason to pursue Kucherov, but his modified no-trade clause and Tampa’s reluctance make this deal unlikely as written.
Assets

- 2027 2nd round pick

- 2027 2nd round pick
- 2029 2nd round pick
Why the model says so
Robertson is an excellent, younger scorer, but Tampa would pay $2.5 million more against the cap and surrender two seconds without gaining contract control beyond this season.
Kucherov gives Dallas a stronger offensive driver for a Cup run at a lower cap hit, and the two Tampa seconds soften the cost of moving Robertson and Nashville’s second.
The deal
Tampa Bay Lightning acquire Jason Robertson and a 2027 2nd-round pick (NSH) from the Dallas Stars for Nikita Kucherov, a 2027 2nd-round pick (TBL) and a 2029 2nd-round pick (TBL).
Team by team
Tampa Bay would get a 27-year-old first-line left wing who scored 45 goals last season, plus Nashville’s 2027 second-rounder. Robertson is also a pending UFA, though, and his $12 million cap hit is $2.5 million higher than Kucherov’s; Tampa would need room for that increase while giving up two of its own seconds.
Dallas would get the more dangerous playmaker for a Cup run: Kucherov had 130 points last season and has 28 in 19 games this season. His $9.5 million cap hit is lower, but he is 33, can become a UFA after the season, and has a modified no-trade clause; the two Tampa seconds help offset the risk of losing Robertson.