Made in Canada
All proposalsEDM / TBL

Kuch To EDM?

cw_user_nizjtq5cOct 31, 2026
33%
chance it happens

Model says TBL says no.

Vote below to see if readers agree.

EDM50%to acceptSays yes

$5.7Mcap space after

TBL33%to acceptSays no

$716Kcap space after

Who says no?

20 votes

Analysis

Tampa Bay likely passes: two future firsts and Savoie make this a serious offer, but replacing Kucherov’s elite production with two older forwards is a poor bet for a team trying to win now. Edmonton would consider the upgrade, though paying that much for a potential one-season rental and losing two regular scorers makes its decision close.

Assets

EDMReceives-$2,011,667
  • Nikita Kucherov
    RW33$9,500,0001 yr, UFA
    2025-26: 76 GP, 44 G, 86 A, 130 P
TBLReceives+$2,011,667
  • Ryan Nugent-Hopkins
    C33$5,125,0003 yrs, UFA
    2025-26: 72 GP, 20 G, 36 A, 56 P
  • Zach Hyman
    LW34$5,500,0002 yrs, UFA
    2025-26: 58 GP, 31 G, 21 A, 52 P
  • Matthew Savoie
    C22$886,6671 yr, RFA
    2025-26: 82 GP, 18 G, 19 A, 37 P
  • 2028 1st round pick
  • 2029 1st round pick

Why the model says so

Kucherov could make Edmonton’s attack even harder to stop, but Hyman, Nugent-Hopkins, Savoie and two firsts are a steep price without a Kucherov extension.

The picks and Savoie give Tampa Bay future upside, but a Cup contender is unlikely to trade Kucherov for older, less productive replacements while he is still scoring at an elite rate.

The deal

Edmonton Oilers acquire Nikita Kucherov from the Tampa Bay Lightning for Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, Zach Hyman, Matthew Savoie, a 2028 1st-round pick (EDM) and a 2029 1st-round pick (EDM).

Team by team

EDM

Edmonton would add an elite playmaking winger to its Cup push: Kucherov scored 130 points last season and carries a $9.5 million cap hit, but he can become a UFA after this season. Sending out Nugent-Hopkins and Hyman removes two established scorers and $10.625 million in combined cap hits, while Savoie is on long-term injured reserve and his $886,667 hit may be offset.

TBL

Tampa Bay would get two first-round picks, a 22-year-old former No. 9 pick in Savoie, and immediate scoring from Hyman and Nugent-Hopkins. Savoie had 37 points last season but is currently on LTIR and needs a new deal after this season; Hyman has one year left after this one at $5.5 million, and Nugent-Hopkins has two at $5.125 million. Their age and contract commitments make this a risky return for a contender built around Kucherov.

Discussion

Discord