Made in Canada
All proposalsDET / TBL

Kuch to Detroit

cw_user_8wgdc0thOct 31, 2026
42%
chance it happens

Model says DET says no.

Vote below to see if readers agree.

DET42%to acceptSays no

$29.45Mcap space after

TBL58%to acceptSays yes

$1.22Mover the cap

Who says no?

21 votes

Analysis

Detroit is more likely to pass: Larkin’s assumed suspension creates pressure to trade him, but adding Edvinsson makes the cost too high for one season of Kucherov at a reduced cap hit and only an assumed willingness to extend. Tampa Bay could consider the center-and-defense package despite Kucherov’s assumed trade request, but losing his scoring now makes this deal unlikely as written.

Assets

DETReceives-$3,950,000
  • Nikita Kucherov
    Nikita Kucherov50% retained
    RW33$4,750,0001 yr, UFA
    2025-26: 76 GP, 44 G, 86 A, 130 P
  • 2027 2nd round pick
  • 2028 3rd round pick
TBLReceives+$3,950,000

Why the model says so

Detroit needs to move Larkin under the stated assumption, but Edvinsson is too much to add for an expiring Kucherov deal without assumed extension terms.

Larkin and Edvinsson are a strong return for a star who has assumedly requested a trade, but Tampa Bay would lose Kucherov’s scoring while trying to win the Cup.

Context provided by the author

Dylan Larkin requested a trade in the summer and has officially refused to participate in any more games moving forward resulting in his suspension. The red wings have some pressure to get a deal done. Edvinsson is also playing hard ball and despite the wings insisting they want to sign him… an opportunity like this could easily be worth it. Kucherov has officially announced his trade request. His 10 team trade list hasn’t been announced but for this scenario let’s assume he has Detroit on his list and is willing to extend.

The deal

Detroit Red Wings acquire Nikita Kucherov (50% retained), a 2027 2nd-round pick (TBL) and a 2028 3rd-round pick (TOR) from the Tampa Bay Lightning for Dylan Larkin and Simon Edvinsson.

Team by team

DET

Detroit would get an elite scorer at a $4.75 million cap hit for this season, plus Tampa Bay’s 2027 second and Toronto’s 2028 third. But Kucherov is 33 and headed for unrestricted free agency; even assuming he is willing to extend, Detroit would be giving up a 30-year-old top-line center under contract for four more years after this season and a 23-year-old first-pair defenseman whose RFA rights it holds. That is a steep price for a bubble team.

TBL

Tampa Bay would lose the winger who scored 130 points last season and retain $4.75 million for this season. Larkin’s assumed refusal to play for Detroit makes him more attainable, though his no-trade clause still matters; Edvinsson gives the contender a young top-pair left defenseman if it can sign the unsigned RFA. Kucherov’s assumed trade request and willingness to go to Detroit make a deal possible, but Tampa Bay would still be moving its best scorer during a Cup push.

Discussion

Discord