$3.82Mcap space after
EDM and TBL trade
Model says TBL says no.
Vote below to see if readers agree.
$2.59Mcap space after
Who says no?
13 votesAnalysis
Tampa likely passes: it is a contender built around Kucherov, and even a substantial package of picks and forwards is a poor reason to trade its best scorer in October. Edmonton would be interested in Kucherov at a retained cap hit, though giving up two firsts, two seconds and Savoie for a player who can leave after this season makes it a costly gamble.
Assets




- 2029 1st round pick
- 2028 1st round pick
- 2027 2nd round pick
- 2030 2nd round pick
Why the model says so
Kucherov could make Edmonton’s top six formidable, but two firsts, two seconds, Savoie and Hyman are a steep price for one season before he can become a UFA.
The firsts and Savoie give Tampa real future value, but Hyman is injured and neither he nor the prospects replaces Kucherov’s offense for a Cup contender.
The deal
Edmonton Oilers acquire Nikita Kucherov (25% retained) from the Tampa Bay Lightning for Zach Hyman, Matthew Savoie, Quinn Hutson, Maksim Berezkin, a 2029 1st-round pick (EDM), a 2028 1st-round pick (EDM), a 2027 2nd-round pick (EDM) and a 2030 2nd-round pick (EDM).
Team by team
Edmonton would add an elite playmaking winger for its Cup run: Kucherov had 130 points last season and has 15 in 12 games this season. Tampa’s 25% retention puts his cap hit at $7.125 million for this season, but he can become a UFA afterward; Edmonton would also lose Hyman’s scoring and Savoie’s young, inexpensive NHL production.
Tampa would get two firsts, two seconds, Savoie and Hyman, but that package does little to replace Kucherov’s offense during its own Cup run. Hyman scored 31 goals last season but is 34, on injured reserve and carries a $5.5 million cap hit through next season; Savoie is on LTIR and becomes an RFA after this season. Hutson is an AHL scorer on a $875,000 deal, while Berezkin is an unsigned prospect whose rights Tampa would hold.
