All proposalsDET / SJS

Just makes too much sense

cw_user_alt5wf1kNov 3, 2026
28%
chance it happens

Model says SJS says no.

Vote below to see if readers agree.

DET63%to acceptSays yes

$23.64Mcap space after

SJS28%to acceptSays no

$9.06Mcap space after

Who says no?

7 votes

Analysis

San Jose is more likely to pass: Edvinsson is a major addition, but Danielson has not shown enough in the NHL to make up for giving away Misa’s franchise-center upside, Sahlin Wallenius and a second. Detroit could consider that bet on Misa, though losing its best young defenseman would make the deal far from automatic.

Assets

DETReceives+$1,042,083
  • Michael Misa
    C19$986,2502 yrs, RFA
    2025-26: 45 GP, 9 G, 12 A, 21 P
  • Leo Sahlin Wallenius
    D20$965,0003 yrs, RFA
    Drafted 2024, #53 overall
  • 2028 2nd round pick
SJSReceives-$1,042,083

Why the model says so

Misa’s No. 2-pick upside, Sahlin Wallenius and the second make this a reasonable offer for Detroit, especially with Edvinsson unsigned. The Wings would still have to accept a big hole on their first pair.

Edvinsson would improve San Jose’s defense, but Danielson’s limited NHL production leaves too much of the return riding on one unsigned RFA. The Sharks are unlikely to add Sahlin Wallenius and a second while moving Misa.

The deal

Detroit Red Wings acquire Michael Misa, Leo Sahlin Wallenius and a 2028 2nd-round pick (SJS) from the San Jose Sharks for Nate Danielson and Simon Edvinsson.

Team by team

DET

Detroit would get a potential top-line center in Misa, the 2025 No. 2 pick, whose 21 points in 45 games last season give more context than his seven points in 15 games this fall. His $986,250 entry-level cap hit runs through next season; Sahlin Wallenius, a 2024 second-round defense prospect with two more years after this one at $965,000, and San Jose’s 2028 second add longer-term value. But Detroit’s bubble roster would lose Edvinsson, an established first-pair defenseman who is unsigned as an RFA and needs a new deal.

SJS

San Jose would get a young first-pair left defenseman in Edvinsson, who had 25 points in 72 games last season and brings strong two-way play, plus Danielson, a 2023 No. 9 pick still trying to establish himself after seven points in 28 games last season. Danielson costs $909,167 through next season; Edvinsson has no current deal, so the Sharks would need to negotiate one. That is a useful return for a rising bubble team, but it costs them their highest-upside center prospect alongside Celebrini.

Discussion1

Discord
CW
cw_user_diuqp020

Interesting