Made in Canada
All proposalsTBL / WSH

I don't even know how to make a trade like this

cw_user_qm9n4dhuOct 31, 2026
28%
chance it happens

Model says TBL says no.

Vote below to see if readers agree.

TBL28%to acceptSays no

$6.11Mcap space after

WSH30%to acceptSays no

$180Kover the cap, $3.97M LTIR relief

Who says no?

13 votes

Analysis

Tampa Bay likely passes: even a strong package of two firsts, Aliaksei Protas and prospects is hard to justify for a contender built around Kucherov. Washington could use his elite scoring, but paying that price for a possible one-season addition makes this trade unlikely to satisfy both clubs.

Assets

TBLReceives-$3,378,333
  • Aliaksei Protas
    LW25$3,375,0003 yrs, UFA
    2025-26: 76 GP, 25 G, 27 A, 52 P
  • Ilya Protas
    LW20$932,5003 yrs, RFA
    2025-26: 4 GP, 1 G, 3 A, 4 P
  • Ivan Miroshnichenko
    LW22$925,0002 yrs, RFA
    2025-26: 13 GP, 2 G, 1 A, 3 P
  • Andrew Cristall
    LW21$889,1672 yrs, RFA
    Drafted 2023, #40 overall
  • 2027 1st round pick
  • 2028 1st round pick
WSHReceives+$3,378,333
  • Nikita Kucherov
    RW33$9,500,0001 yr, UFA
    2025-26: 76 GP, 44 G, 86 A, 130 P

Why the model says so

The two firsts and Aliaksei Protas make this a serious offer, but Tampa Bay is trying to win the Cup now and would lose its best scorer without a comparable replacement.

Kucherov could lift Washington’s offense, but a bubble team would be risking two unprotected firsts and four young forwards for a player who can become a UFA after this season.

The deal

Tampa Bay Lightning acquire Aliaksei Protas, Ilya Protas, Ivan Miroshnichenko, Andrew Cristall, a 2027 1st-round pick (WSH) and a 2028 1st-round pick (WSH) from the Washington Capitals for Nikita Kucherov.

Team by team

TBL

Tampa Bay would get two unprotected Washington firsts, a 25-year-old 52-point winger in Aliaksei Protas at $3.375 million for three seasons, and three young forwards. Miroshnichenko was a #20 pick but has yet to stick in the NHL; Cristall scored 60 AHL points last season, while Ilya Protas is still establishing himself. That is a substantial future return, but it does not replace Kucherov’s scoring on a Cup contender.

WSH

Washington would add a 33-year-old winger who scored 130 points last season and has 28 in 19 games this season. Kucherov’s $9.5 million cap hit expires after this season, and his modified no-trade clause could limit the deal; Washington would also have to fit his salary while giving up Aliaksei Protas’s affordable production and two unprotected firsts that carry real risk for a bubble team.

Discussion

Discord