All proposalsCGY / BOS

My Trade Offer

cw_user_jcb6uw05Jul 14, 2026
Very Unlikely19%

Who says no?

7 votes

Readers say CGY. The model says BOS.

Assets

CGYReceives+$250,000
  • Poitras, Matthew
    $0
  • Jokiharju, Henri
    $3,000,000
  • 2028 2nd round pick
BOSReceives-$250,000
  • Whitecloud, Zach
    $2,750,000

Who says no?

CGYLikely Accepts93%

They turn one mid-priced, short-term RD into a young RFA center with upside, another controllable RD, and a 2nd-round pick, which is a clear surplus of value and fits a deep rebuild.

Readers
43%say they block it
BOSLikely Rejects19%

They give up Poitras’ RFA rights, Jokiharju’s extra year of control, and a 2nd-rounder for a non-elite RD on a short-term deal, which is far beyond typical market cost for this caliber of defender.

Readers
14%say they block it

The deal

Calgary Flames acquire a 2028 second-round pick, Matthew Poitras, and Henri Jokiharju from the Boston Bruins for Zach Whitecloud.

Team by team

CGY

For rebuilding Calgary, moving Zach Whitecloud (1 year left at $2.75M before UFA) for a young RFA center in Matthew Poitras (needs a new deal but still in his early 20s), a right-shot defender with one extra year of control in Henri Jokiharju ($3M, UFA after one more season), and a 2028 BOS 2nd adds both a longer control window on the right side and a higher-upside, cost-controlled center plus a future asset that fits their timeline.

BOS

For Boston, consolidating two mid-tier right-shot defensemen and a young but unproven RFA center plus a future 2nd into Zach Whitecloud gives them a stable, low-cost ($2.75M) defensive RD for two playoff runs, but it significantly overpays in futures and depth for a non-top-pair defender on an expiring window.

Analysis

Value is heavily tilted toward Calgary: Poitras’ RFA rights plus Jokiharju’s extra year and a 2nd-round pick is too rich for a solid but non-impact RD on a short-term deal, making this unrealistic from Boston’s perspective. Calgary’s side fits a rebuild perfectly, while Boston would be sacrificing too much future and depth for only a modest upgrade on the right side.

Discussion1

Discord
MP
F
MrPpyBtthl

Prior to free agency, I think Boston makes this trade all day.