Made in Canada
All proposalsDET / TBL / MTL

Who say no

cw_user_wdgkocxcOct 31, 2026
20%
chance it happens

Model says TBL says no.

Vote below to see if readers agree.

DET48%to acceptSays no

$30.6Mcap space after

TBL20%to acceptSays no

$2.63Mcap space after

MTL67%to acceptSays yes

$5.26Mover the cap

Who says no?

13 votes

Analysis

Tampa Bay is the likeliest holdout: a Cup contender would be giving up Kucherov’s elite offense for a good first-line center and an unproven defenseman. Detroit could consider the futures package, and Montréal could justify paying it for a playoff push, but the deal is unlikely without a stronger return for Tampa Bay.

Assets

DETReceives-$5,100,000
  • Kirby Dach
    C25$3,600,0001 yr, UFAfromMTL
    2025-26: 37 GP, 8 G, 7 A, 15 P
  • Michael Hage
    C20UnsignedfromMTL
    Drafted 2024, #21 overall
  • 2027 1st round pick
    fromMTL
TBLReceives+$96,667
  • Dylan Larkin
    C30$8,700,0005 yrs, UFAfromDET
    2025-26: 74 GP, 34 G, 33 A, 67 P
  • Adam Engstrom
    D23$896,6671 yr, RFAfromMTL
    2025-26: 15 GP, 0 G, 1 A, 1 P
MTLReceives+$5,003,333
  • Nikita Kucherov
    RW33$9,500,0001 yr, UFAfromTBL
    2025-26: 76 GP, 44 G, 86 A, 130 P

Why the model says so

Hage and Montréal’s first give Detroit a credible start on a longer-term return, but that pick could be late and Dach is a pending UFA. Giving up Larkin’s five seasons of control is a close call.

Larkin is a strong center under contract for five seasons, but Engstrom does not close the gap between him and Kucherov’s game-breaking offense. Tampa Bay is built to contend now.

Kucherov could transform Montréal’s attack for a playoff run, and Hage plus its first are the main costs. The risk is paying that price for a 33-year-old who can leave after this season.

The deal

Detroit Red Wings acquire Kirby Dach, Michael Hage and a 2027 1st-round pick (MTL) from the Montréal Canadiens; Tampa Bay Lightning acquire Dylan Larkin from the Detroit Red Wings and Adam Engstrom from the Montréal Canadiens; Montréal Canadiens acquire Nikita Kucherov from the Tampa Bay Lightning.

Team by team

DET

Detroit is near the bottom of the bubble, so moving Larkin could make sense if it chooses to build for later. Hage, an unsigned 2024 first-round center, and Montréal’s 2027 first carry the return; Dach is a $3.6 million pending UFA whose 15 points in 37 games last season make him a risky replacement for Larkin.

TBL

Tampa Bay would replace Kucherov’s $9.5 million expiring deal with Larkin at $8.7 million for this season and four more, plus Engstrom, a young defenseman on an expiring entry-level deal. Montréal would get an elite scorer coming off 130 points, but Kucherov can become a UFA after this season, and his $9.5 million cap hit and modified no-trade clause complicate the move.

Discussion

Discord