Made in Canada
All proposalsTBL / TOR

TBL and TOR trade

cw_user_6fq4c9hoOct 31, 2026
17%
chance it happens

Model says TOR says no.

Vote below to see if readers agree.

TBL64%to acceptSays yes

$7Mcap space after

TOR17%to acceptSays no

$2.6Mover the cap, $10.22M LTIR relief

Who says no?

33 votes

Analysis

Toronto is more likely to pass: Kucherov is a game-changing scorer, but McKenna, Cowan and two firsts are too much for one season of him without an extension. Tampa Bay is a Cup contender built around Kucherov, yet that return is strong enough to make moving him plausible if his clause permits it.

Assets

TBLReceives-$4,275,000
  • Gavin McKenna
    LW18$1,075,0003 yrs, RFA
    Drafted 2026, #1 overall
  • Easton Cowan
    RW21$900,0002 yrs, RFA
    2025-26: 66 GP, 11 G, 18 A, 29 P
  • Dakota Joshua
    C30$3,250,0002 yrs, UFA
    2025-26: 55 GP, 10 G, 8 A, 18 P
  • 2027 1st round pick
  • 2029 1st round pick
TORReceives+$4,275,000
  • Nikita Kucherov
    RW33$9,500,0001 yr, UFA
    2025-26: 76 GP, 44 G, 86 A, 130 P

Why the model says so

Tampa Bay would hate losing Kucherov during a Cup run, but McKenna, Cowan and two firsts are a strong return for a pending UFA.

Toronto would get an elite scorer, but giving up McKenna, Cowan and two firsts for a player who can leave after this season is too steep.

The deal

Tampa Bay Lightning acquire Gavin McKenna, Easton Cowan, Dakota Joshua, a 2027 1st-round pick (COL) and a 2029 1st-round pick (TOR) from the Toronto Maple Leafs for Nikita Kucherov.

Team by team

TBL

Tampa Bay would give up a 33-year-old elite scorer who had 130 points last season and has 18 in 13 games this season. McKenna, the 2026 No. 1 pick, is already producing in the NHL on a $1.075 million entry-level deal; Cowan adds a young winger on a $900,000 deal, and the two firsts add substantial future value. Joshua is a useful third-line winger, though his $3.25 million cap hit runs through next season.

TOR

Toronto would get Kucherov for a playoff push, but his $9.5 million cap hit is a major increase over the $5.225 million combined cap hits it sends out. He can become a UFA after this season, and his modified no-trade clause could affect the deal; the value of Colorado’s 2027 first and Toronto’s 2029 first depends on where those picks land.

Discussion1

Discord
CW
cw_user_3wbfqwql

1st overall pick, 2nd best young player & 2 firsts for a rental?