$2.2Mcap space after
Kucherov
Model says TBL says no.
Vote below to see if readers agree.
$3.73Mcap space after
Who says no?
21 votesAnalysis
Tampa Bay likely passes: Dubois and an uncertain first-round pick do not replace Kucherov’s offense for a team trying to win the Cup now. Washington would be tempted by the upgrade, though Kucherov’s modified no-trade clause could also affect whether the deal happens.
Assets

- 2027 1st round pick
Why the model says so
Washington would probably take the chance to add Kucherov’s scoring, but losing its own first and Dubois’s long-term center role for a potential rental gives it pause.
Tampa Bay would give up its top scorer during a Cup push for a second-line center on a long contract and a first-round pick with no guaranteed premium slot.
The deal
Washington Capitals acquire Nikita Kucherov from the Tampa Bay Lightning for Pierre-Luc Dubois and a 2027 1st-round pick (WSH).
Team by team
Washington is a bubble team, but Kucherov would give it an elite scoring winger: he had 130 points last season and has 15 in 12 games this season. His $9.5 million cap hit is $1 million above Dubois’s, and he can become a UFA after this season; Washington would need to weigh that rental risk against giving up its own 2027 first.
Tampa Bay is a Cup contender built around Kucherov, so Dubois is not a like-for-like replacement. He is a capable two-way second-line center, but his recent average is 42 points per season, and his $8.5 million cap hit runs four more years after this one. Washington’s first could be a strong pick if its bubble season turns, but its draft slot is uncertain.
